While the Los Angeles Dodgers are shelling out all sorts of millions of dollars for what has been barely replacement-level pitching overall, the Houston Astros have made quite the surge in our pitching staff power rankings in spite of a starting rotation that is mostly replacement arms these days.

With a third week in a row atop our list, Detroit becomes the team with the most consecutive weeks at No. 1 in 2025.

From inflated reputations to underwhelming stats, here are the 15 most overrated catchers in MLB history who didn’t quite live up to the hype